I was talking to someone who shall be nameless about "certain people" who harp on how the Central Park Five should still be in jail. Now the Central Park Five were falsely accused, and convicted, based on coerced confessions and a lot of cover-up of things like the fact that none of their DNA matched the DNA in the case. But to "certain people" they should be still in jail because (1) if they were innocent, why did they confess in the first place? and (2) "These young men do not exactly have the pasts of angels."
My response to #2 is, "Who does?" and give them a steady stare.*
My response to #1 is, there's a long list of reasons. The obvious reasons that they were juveniles (four were 15, one was 16), interrogated for hours, without counsel, without food (Dylan Roof was given Burger King takeout), and violence. (One of the defendants said, "I would hear them beating up Korey Wise in the next room", and "they would come and look at me and say: 'You realize you're next.' The fear made me feel really like I was not going to be able to make it out." Wikipedia)
My response to #1 is, there's a long list of reasons. The obvious reasons that they were juveniles (four were 15, one was 16), interrogated for hours, without counsel, without food (Dylan Roof was given Burger King takeout), and violence. (One of the defendants said, "I would hear them beating up Korey Wise in the next room", and "they would come and look at me and say: 'You realize you're next.' The fear made me feel really like I was not going to be able to make it out." Wikipedia)
And there's also the reason that (in my experience) young adolescents have a self-destruct button built into them which is inexplicable, unpredictable, and always hits at the wrong damn time in the wrong damn way. Adolescent males are of most notorious for a tendency to direct their violence outwardly, as in every freaking school shooter we've ever seen. But the self-destruct button hits both sexes in self-harm (cutting etc.), running away, running off with the absolute wrong/worst person possible, and/or suicide attempts, all of which are different ways of giving up on life. Because they don't see any way out and / or they no longer give a damn. Confessing to a crime you didn't commit is another way of doing it.
One example of this was done by Agatha Christie in Towards Zero, in which two characters - Sergeant Battle's daughter (a minor character) gives up and confesses to a crime she didn't commit, which stumps Battle. Why would she do that? Why? He cannot understand - but because of his daughter, he can see and believe someone else…
And of course, in James Baldwin's If Beale Street Could Talk, Fonny is falsely accused of raping a woman, and arrested and jailed before trial. It's a slam-dunk case for the prosecutor, because a cop places him at the scene of the crime, Fonny has priors, as does his primary witness to his innocence, and he is black. The result? He ends up accepting a plea deal and serves time - years of time - for a crime he didn't do.
Sometimes the law works against you. Sometimes life works against you. Drugs, hard knocks, poverty, and other disasters - "If it wasn't for bad luck, I wouldn't have no luck at all" - can easily lead to a hopelessness that can be summed up in "What the hell." Whether it's confessing, killing, suicide, or cutting yourself to the bone.
Or running away: 99% of runaways leave home because home is a lousy place to be. Most of them leave broke, with the clothes on their backs, and all the self-worth of a sandflea. It makes them very vulnerable, easy targets for drug dealers, pimps, cons, gangs, cults, and anyone who shows them a hint of attention. "What the hell. It just doesn't matter." To anything anyone does to them or with them.
And it's not just inmates and runaways. I've seen a few college students hit a crisis and literally sandbag their entire lives. One I knew was making straight A's, and then something happened (I never did find out what), and he literally quit coming to class the last 2 weeks. I chased him down and told him if he'd come take the final, he could probably pull out a "D" (as in "D" for "done") or maybe even a "C". And he said, sure, he would - but he didn't. And so he flunked. My class, every class, and dropped out of school. No idea what happened after that.
I think the self-destruct button is far more common than any of us like to think.
Isn't that what most mid-life crises are? Figuring, "What the hell", and going out and doing some incredibly stupid crap - from drugs to crime to skeevy relationships - that you may well be too old to survive?
And then there's long-lasting trauma. I can't tell you how many people I'm talking to who are worn out, exhausted, and struggling with depression and even despair because of 2020 - I mean pandemic, politics, wildfires, hurricanes, and the economy all wrap up to make it hard to stay always cheerful and bright. Not to mention the constant gaslighting. Check out this wonderful article by DS Leiter:
Not to mention some of our politicians. Our own Governor, Kristi Noem, said last week at a Rotary event (after we passed the 14,000 case mark), that "I won't be changing my recommendations that I can see in the near future. I think this is where we expected we would be. None of this is a surprise. Originally, based on modeling, (our) peak day in June, we would have up to 10,000 people in the hospital in South Dakota that had COVID-19." (Argus Leader) In other words, until we have 10,000 people in the hospital in South Dakota, life will continue to go on as normal. Of course, with only 880,000 people in the entire state, 10,000 hospitalized would mean the whole state has it, but what the hey.
Meanwhile, our Governor is having a great time. Here she is at September 4th's South Dakota State Fair Bull Bash (Huron Plainsman) Photo from Twitter:
Sigh...
Anyway, I'm certain that a lot of people are hearing [one of] the voices in their head** saying, "What the hell. Maybe we should just go ahead and catch the damn virus and get it over with." Except that the prognosis for 100% recovery from COVID-19 is decreasing rapidly with every new batch of information we get. Or "What the hell. Maybe we just won't vote - it won't do any good anyway." Well, you can figure out your own reasons why that's bull.
All I can say is that this year, this pandemic, and life under almost any circumstances is a marathon, not a sprint. Don't let the voices in your head get to you, and don't hit the self-destruct button.
“Nolite te Bastardes Carborundorum”***
* If you have lived an angelic past, God bless you and keep you, but we're going to run out of things to talk about. And I probably won't believe you.
** Someday I should write a blog post about the voices, but don't expect it to be coherent. As I tell my fellow Al-Anons, that I don't call mine "the committee" because committees are organized.
*** Yes, I know that isn't proper Latin. 😎 I like it anyway.