Like many of our readers here at SleuthSayers, I love short stories. I love reading them and writing them, and I've been doing both for a long time. Writing shorts, for me, started thirty years ago--I submitted my first stories in late 1993--and even then I leaned toward mystery/crime stories. I also wrote some westerns, science fiction, etc.--and still do--but I especially like mysteries.
I won't get into a lot of things about markets and marketing, but I will mention that two of my stories have appeared in the past few weeks in two of my favorite mystery publications: Alfred Hitchcock's Mystery Magazine and Sherlock Holmes Mystery Magazine. AHMM, as most of you know, has been around since the 1950s and publishes once every two months, and SHMM started out maybe a dozen years ago and publishes irregularly--but both have been good to me and both have editors I like and admire.
My story in AHMM (Nov/Dec 2023 issue) is "The Zeller Files," and is different in a couple of ways from what I usually write. This story is a mix of two genres--crime and science fiction. It's about a guy named Eddie Zeller, who once survived an alien abduction and was told by his captors that they would return for him someday. When he and his wife Lisa discover that another couple supposedly kidnapped in the past by these same otherworldly beings have recently moved to the town where the Zellers live, Eddie fears that these alien forces might be gathering all the onetime abductees together so they can again be taken, in one swoop--and maybe this time for more than just observation and release. There is also a crime involved, and there's a fair amount of the chasing and zapping and paranoia that you usually find in an X-Files kind of story.
The second difference about this particular tale is that it's one of only a few stories I've sold that were set during the height of the Covid-19 pandemic, with the characters wearing masks and avoiding crowds and dealing with a whole different kind of paranoia. I think both these oddities made the story more fun to write, and--who knows?--might've been what appealed to the editor. At any rate, I was grateful but surprised when AHMM bought it.
The other story is "The Three Little Biggs," in Sherlock Holmes Mystery Magazine (Issue #32). Its a little different also, from my usual, but it's on the other end of the spectrum from the AHMM story. "The Zeller Files" is longish (5600 words), it's more SF than mystery, it's sort of intense, it's set in the (recent) past, it has only a few characters, and it's a standalone story. "Biggs" is short (900 words), it's a whodunit, it's lighthearted, it's present-day, it has a lot of characters, and it's a series story. In fact it's the umpteenth installment of what I long ago started calling my "Law and Daughter" mysteries, featuring small-town sheriff Lucy Valentine and her bossy mother Frances.
In this story, Lucy and Fran investigate the strange death of wealthy rancher Elijah Biggs, whose three weird offspring have gathered at the ranch to celebrate his birthday and found his dead body instead. There's a lot of inheritance-squabbling between the siblings in this story (I told a friend last week that it's a bad-heir-day mystery), and if you read it I hope you'll find that the solution fits Aristotle's famous description of endings that are "both unexpected and inevitable."
Quick questions. Everyone reading this probably knows about AHMM, but are all of you familiar with Sherlock Holmes Mystery Magazine? (It's a publication of Wildside Press and the editor is Carla Coupe.) Have any of you submitted stories to them, or been published there? If so, have you found them easy to work with? Please let me know in the comments. I really like the magazine, I've had a number of stories published there over the years, and I hope it'll be around for many more.
How could anyone resist two magazines with those names in their titles?
Coming attraction: In two weeks my friend Josh Pachter will be here to tell you about his--and several of our--experiences with a new short-fiction market called Storia.
See you then.
Congratulations again, John. The variety of your stories never ceases to amaze. As for SHMM, every time I check their guidelines, they’ re closed to submissions. Are they by invitation only?
ReplyDeleteEdward Lodi
Hi Edward -- Thanks so much. As for variety, I have sort of a selfish reason for that. I think it's a good way for writers to keep from getting bored with their stories. Even in the mystery genre, I try to come up with different *kinds* of crimes and characters, etc., because it's more fun to do it that way.
DeleteRegarding SHMM, no, they're not invitation only. And since I've not submitted to them in a while, I didn't realize they might not be open now to submissions. I'll ask the editor and let you know about that.
John, I had the same experience as Edward! Thanks for looking into that for us. You may have figured out that I am absolutely awed by the number of your publications! Not to mention quality. I have never called myself a 'fangirl' before, but I do rate among your greatest fans.
ReplyDeleteMelodie, I've sent the SHMM editor that question (are they closed to submissions?) in an email, and I hope I'll hear back from her in time to put the answer in the comments today. If not I'll get back to you personally, and Edward and Susan too. It's really been a good while since I sent SH a submission.
DeleteAs for your VERY kind words, thank you sincerely. And believe me, the fan thing goes both ways--I've been reading your Goddaughter books, and far's I'm concerned, Gina Gallo is right up there with Stephanie Plum. What a great character--the books are wonderful!
Thanks again, and keep writing!
Congratulations on your recent publications, John. I too had the question about submissions to SHMM. Are they open or not? Susan Oleksiw
ReplyDeleteThank you, Susan! See my response to Mel, above--I hope the answer will be that Carla's still open to new submissions. Will let you know.
DeleteJohn, you amaze me ...and always teach me something...
ReplyDeleteKeep on trucking!
How kind of you, Ann. Thank you. And thanks for stopping in at SleuthSayers!
DeleteCarla is a wonderful editor. She's accepted three of my stories for SHMM (only one's been published so far), and she accepted several of my stories for Black Cat Mystery Magazine when she was that magazine's editor. A writer can't go wrong slipping a story into SHMM's submission queue whenever it is open for submissions.
ReplyDeleteMichael, she's great. Like you, I had several stories accepted by her when she was at Black Cat Mystery Magazine (I think that was the way I first "met" her), and I think she was the editor who accepted most of the seven that I've sold to SHMM--I've forgotten which ones were accepted by Carla and which by the previous editor. Yes, they do sometimes take quite a while to publish accepted stories.
DeleteYou're also right that it's always a good idea to send SHMM something anytime the window's open--I'm still hoping to hear something back from Carla about that question today. Have YOU heard whether they might now be considering submissions?
Alas, no.
DeleteI just got an answer back from Carla Coupe, to the question "Are you currently open or closed to submissions?"
ReplyDeleteShe said they're now accepting only Sherlock Holmes pastiches and nonfiction articles. Currently closed to other short story submissions.
Hope this helps.
smoking...why not....
ReplyDeleteLucky to have a couple of stories in SHMM! No luck with AHMM yet!
ReplyDeleteKeep trying, Jeff!
DeleteThanks!
Delete