One thing I've found, as a writer, is that if you get into the habit of writing and submitting short stories to editors regularly, you can usually--not always--expect to sell and get them published regularly. Sure, there are dry spells, we all have those. But if you set a good pace and don't let too much time pass between submissions, all those swallows you send out are eventually going to find their way back to Capistrano--and sometimes they come in flocks. Rejections? Sure you'll get rejections. But if you're careful to send out the best work that you can do, you'll probably find that the writer who gets the most no's is also the one who gets the most yeses.
Publishingwise, the first half of December was good to me this year. I had a story published in the December issue of Mystery Magazine, one in a Golden Age of Mystery anthology, one in the third Mickey Finn: 21st Century Noir anthology, one in AHMM, one in Kings River Life, and one in an anthology of previous Shamus Award-winning stories. All of those tales are firmly in the mystery/suspense genre, but most are very different in terms of location, mood, characters, time period, type of crime, etc. If you're at all interested, here are quick summaries of those six stories.
"The Magnolia Thief," Mystery Magazine, December 2022 issue. This is the umpteenth installation of my "Law & Daughter" series featuring Sheriff Lucy Valentine and her crimesolving mother Fran. It's a lighthearted solve-it-yourself mystery about traveling salesmen, motel restaurants, and the theft of a valuable painting of the state flower that was given to the local mayor by the governor. Side note: "The Magnolia Thief" is my seventh story in Mystery Magazine this year--four more have been accepted by MM but not yet published--and my fifth Fran/Lucy story there.
"Burying Oliver," Mickey Finn, Vol. 3: 21st Century Noir (Down & Out Books), edited by Michael Bracken. My story in the third Mickey Finn outing is a standalone tale featuring a young farmer, his wife, his cousin, his dog, and the local sheriff--and, as you might expect, some of those five don't make it out alive. (Actually, most of them don't make it out alive.) "Burying Oliver" probably has more plot twists in its 3000 words than any other story I've written recently, which is one of the things that made this one such a pleasure to create. Quick plug, here: Michael Bracken anthologies are always fun, both to write for and to read, and this book is no exception.
"Old Money," Edgar & Shamus Go Golden (Down & Out Books), edited by Gay Kinman and Andrew McAleer. This anthology contains twelve original stories set in the Golden Age of Mystery, all written by winners of either the Edgar or Shamus Award. The one I wrote specifically for this book, "Old Money," features New Orleans private eye Luke Walker, and is set mostly in 1940s Natchez, Mississippi. The crimes involved are insurance fraud and murder, and the story was great fun to write because of two things: (1) the research I had to do regarding language, cars, businesses, cigarettes, equipment, procedures, buildings, etc., of that time period, and (2) my familiarity with the city of Natchez.
"Going the Distance," Alfred Hitchcock's Mystery Magazine (Jan/Feb 2023 issue). This is the seventh installment of my series about Sheriff Ray Douglas of Pine County, Mississippi, where a rare Christmas snowstorm serves to complicate an already weird murder investigation. Also featured are Douglas's loyal deputy Cheryl Grubbs and his off-and-on love interest Jennifer Parker. (Even though this issue is dated January/February, I'm told it went on sale this past week, on Dec. 13.) FYI, the eighth Ray Douglas mystery has been accepted by AHMM but is still awaiting a publication date.
"Santa's Helper," Kings River Life, December 14, 2022, issue. Most of my KRL stories over the years have been reprints, but this one's an original Christmas mystery--another installment in my Fran and Lucy Valentine series. In this adventure my amateur sleuth and her sheriff daughter investigate the mugging of pint-sized Al Wilson, half of a two-man team who often perform at Christmas events and parties: Al's giant brother Ernest plays Santa and Al plays what he calls a subordinate Claus with low elf esteem. Obviously, this is an ultra-lighthearted story, and is being given double duty: editor Lorie Lewis Ham is featuring it now in the magazine and will run it again next Christmas as a Mysteryrat's Maze Podcast. Thanks, Lorie!
"Mustang Sally," The Shamus Winners: America's Best Private Eye Stories, Vol. III (Perfect Crime Books), edited by Robert Randisi. This is an anthology of all the Shamus Award-winning stories from 2010 to 2021. My story was originally published in Black Cat Mystery Magazine #7: Special Private Eye Issue and was the first installment of my series about present-day private investigator Tom Langford, who takes a case involving the recovery of an engagement ring that went missing under highly unusual circumstances. I was notified this past week that the book is out now but available only via Barnes & Noble. Amazon and other outlets will be getting it soon.
One special thing about these "early Christmas gifts for me" is that three of these six publications happened only because of my fellow SleuthSayer Michael Bracken. Michael was the editor who bought "Burying Oliver" for Mickey Finn, Vol. 3, and he's also the editor who first published "Mustang Sally" in Black Cat Mystery Magazine--a story that went on to win the 2021 Shamus Award and was thus included in the Shamus Winners III anthology. In addition, that Shamus win is the only reason I was invited to write "Old Money" for the Edgar & Shamus Go Golden anthology. So thank you, Michael, for making all three of those publications possible.
Questions, regarding my spree of good luck: Have any of you writers experienced these "when it rains, it pours" spells, with the stories you've submitted? Do you find that these clusters of publications happen more often around the end of the year (because of the approaching holidays, I guess) than at other times? Do you often experience long stretches when nothing you send out seems to be getting published, no matter how often you submit or how hard you try? (I found Bob Mangeot's recent SleuthSayers column on that subject to be interesting.) How do you deal with extended periods of rejection? I can't help recalling what one writer told me years ago, back when everything was done via snailmail. She said she'd found a sure-fire way to prevent getting rejection letters: don't include SASEs. And it worked.
But don't do that. Follow this advice instead: When you get a rejection, send that story someplace else, and then send a different story to the place that rejected you. Never give up, never stop trying. Persistence will pay off, and sometimes in bunches.
Anyhow, that's my pre-Christmas message. I wish all of you a happy and healthy holiday, and many, many publications during the second half of the month--and in 2023!
See you again here on New Year's Eve.
Congratulations, John. Your output is impressive! I just put Edgar & Shamus Go Golden on my wishlist.
ReplyDeleteI wish y'all a merry Christmas!
Thanks, Anne--Merry Christmas to you too! (Stay warm, over there.)
DeleteI hope you'll enjoy the book.
Congratulations, John. You're a role model for all of us. My track record is nothing like yours, but your advice is always spot-on. --Susan Oleksiw
ReplyDeleteSusan, you're too kind. As for track records . . . I'd have to check, but I suspect my rejections are still outnumbering my acceptances and publications. The fact that I'm calling attention to the luck I've had over the past few weeks is proof that it's unusual.
DeleteMain thing is, keep at it!
Thanks as always for your thoughts. Have a great holiday!
Congratulations! And I totally agree - never give up on a story, or a place to submit. Keep trying.
ReplyDeleteHi Eve. Yep, I never EVER give up on a story. I like to tell folks (and it's the truth) that I once had a story rejected two dozen times (It was maybe 2500 words) and eventually wound up selling it, virtually unchanged, to a high-paying market. If you play this writing/submitting game long enough, you get a feel for whether a story is marketable, and if it is you just keep sending it out until it finds the right home.
DeleteCongratulations, John. You have an outstanding track record.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Jacquie. I have been fortunate with sales, but I'll say again, I also get a bunch of rejections. Seems that one of these days I'd learn to how to get past that . . .
DeleteSolid advice. One of my recent sales was to a publisher I'd been submitting to unsuccessfully for years. The piece they accepted had been turned down by four lesser-known magazines. So, yes, keep on pounding.
ReplyDeleteThat's good to hear, Mike. Congrats on sticking with it till it got sold. As you say, that can sometimes result in an even better deal.
DeleteI love to try places where I've not had success in the past. If you get rejected again, nothing's lost except time, and if you get an acceptance all those previous rejections suddenly go away and you never even think about them again. Mind games, yes, but it's true.
Congrats on another great month, John! And yes, I certainly go through periods when the acceptances are coming fast and furious, as well as periods when the rejections rain down upon me. Just the law of averages, I think, creating what look like patterns. I try to get any rejected story back out to another market in under 24 hours.
ReplyDeleteHey Joe. It is indeed the law of averages, and the only way to be sure to win (and sometimes just to break even) is to keep trying. I used to tell my writing students, "I can't guarantee you'll sell a story if you submit it--but I CAN guarantee you won't if you don't."
DeleteGood for you, for sending those rejections out again right away. I have a writer friend who always pores over those rejected stories trying to find ways to fix them before sending them out again. I usually don't do that, and in fact I consider it wasted time. They probably don't *need* fixing. I just submit them someplace else, as is.
Thanks for the thoughts!
Finishing strong! Of course, it's not like you ever slow down. Congrats, and you remain an inspiration.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Bob--how kind of you. Feeling pretty slow *today*--it's cold cold cold here.
DeleteWishing you and family a happy Christmas and a great New Year. Take care!
You're a good man, John Floyd. Congratulations on all your success.
ReplyDeleteBarb, you are too kind. Thank you sincerely. Any success I might've had is probably due to good advice--including yours--from writer and editor friends over the years. I so appreciate you and all of them.
DeleteHave a good Christmas, and keep warm!