When I started taking writing seriously, I aimed to produce a novel every year or so, along with three or four short stories. When I published my first novel, I had five more in my files and I revised them and built off those early ideas for the next decade. In late 2019, I finally exhausted that back inventory, and in the interim, I published 15 novels, but seldom more than two or three short stories a year.
For reasons I've discussed before, that changed in 2020. I haven't even considered writing another novel, but I wrote about fifteen short stories in the last half-year and sold five of them, more than usual. Right now, I have a dozen stories under submission at some market or another, and I owe that to anthologies.
Looking over my records, I see that over half my sales have been to anthologies, which I never realized before. In fact, five of the submissions currently out there are either at anthology markets or were inspired by an anthology call.
What happened?
Well, sometimes I write a story and it turns out to be a perfect match for an anthologoy that appears later. That happened with "Ugly Fat." I wrote the story years ago and many markets turned it down, but I knew it would find a home eventually. Sure enough, Heartbreaks and Half-Truths sought stories about love gone wrong, and "Ugly Fat" was perfect. When I sent it, I was sure it would sell.
I like anthologies more and more now because the guidelines serve as a writing prompt. The general premise and a context generate enough of an idea to get me started. If I get an idea right away, it tells me it's too obvious and other people will think of it, too. If that happens, I usually write a couple of pages and put the story in a file until I find a better idea or a new twist that will make it stand out. Having that basic plan gives me a more specific understanding of where to look for that difference.
For example, Michael Bracken is editing an anthology that will appear next year. "Groovy Gumshoes" showcases PI stories set in the 1960s, and the guidelines encouraged authors to use an historical event from the period. I thought of Woodstock; Vietnam; civil rights; the British music invasion; and the assassinations of the Kennedys, Martin Luther King, Medger Evers and Malcolm X. Two other events spoke to me more personally, though. The Detroit riot erupted less than 30 miles south of where I was in a summer session at Oakland University. The following year, the Detroit Tigers became the first team to come back from a 3-1 game deficit and win the World Series. The riot suggested urban grit, and I used that setting. The story sold.
I have submitted stories to seven Mystery Writer of America antholgies because their themes are concrete enough to generate an idea but open enough to provide wiggle room. So far, only one story I wrote made the anthology in question, but all the others eventually sold somewhere else. I can live with that.
Yes, many anthologies pay a royalty share instead of a flat rate, and that share may be tiny, but anthologies have a longer shelf life than a magazine. Last December, I received (another) royalty payment for an MWA anthology published in 2012.That means the book and my name are still out there, and the exposure builds cred for the next story I submit somewhere else.
As anthologies proliferate, there are more potential markets...and more potential ideas.
It's all about keeping the keyboard warm.
Great read, Steve. More and more of the stories I write are for anthologies, for exactly the reason you name here: the built-in writing prompt. I also really enjoy working with the editors and getting to know the other writers a little as we promote the book, though that will be more fun once we can get back to doing in-person signings and such.
ReplyDeleteOddly enough I've found the toughest nut to crack is the Bouchercon anthology; I've been rejected from the last five. All of those stories have sold elsewhere, though, so it's still been well worth the time. Here's hoping we continue to see lots of interesting anthologies in the coming years.
Writing for themed anthologies can be risky. If your story doesn't make the cut, it becomes one of dozens of similar stories making the rounds of other publications. So, placing it elsewhere may be difficult.
ReplyDeleteI sometimes let my themed-anthology rejects rest a bit before sending them back out on the presumption that all the other rejected stories are clogging up slush piles. If I let mine rest a year or so, that initial wave of submissions has passed and my story (especially if a minor edit makes it less obviously a reject from a themed anthology) has a better chance of consideration.
Your keyboard isn't merely warm, it's smokin'!
ReplyDelete