04 January 2025

Report Card for 2024


  

Whoa, another year gone. As usual, there were ups and downs, in life and in writing. Overall, I had a good time.

In what has become my custom, inspired mostly by laziness since it requires no creativity at all, I have put together some numbers from, and thoughts about, my so-called writing career (I hate the word journey) over the past year.

As it turned out, I wasn't as productive in 2024 as I was in the past three or four years. I'm not complaining--I sold a number of stories, and I feel fortunate every time one of mine is accepted OR published.  I once heard a smart writer say that it's the height of arrogance for any of us to expect the things we dream up in the middle of the night to be read and enjoyed by people we don't even know. I agree, and believe me, I'm counting my blessings.


Statistics

- I had 33 short stories published in 2024, and 46 more are upcoming, having been accepted but not yet released. That "upcoming" number is actually 28, because 18 of those 46 are stories that'll be included in a collection of my detective tales, which the publisher tells me is scheduled for mid- to late 2025. 

- I wrote 23 new stories in 2024, about the same as last year. Six of those have already been accepted and published; seven have been accepted but not yet published; eight have been sent out but haven't yet received a response; one hasn't yet been submitted anywhere; and one was submitted, rejected, and has not yet been re-deployed. (It will be, though, and soon.)

- I submitted 52 stories this year (an all-time low for me) and got 37 acceptances and 15 rejections. 

- I had 19 stories published in anthologies this year and 11 in magazines, a much wider gap than in previous years. I think the best way to explain that is to say that many of my accepted stories for anthologies will be appearing next year. Three more stories this year were published in animated form, in a market which I consider to be neither magazine nor anthology. (More on that later.)

- Again this year, almost all my published stories were mysteries as opposed to other genres--in fact, 32 of the 33 were straight mystery/crime or mixed-genre crime. The other story was sort of humor/mainstream. As for the mixed-genre stories, two were crime/fantasy and three were crime/Western.

Ten of my published stories in 2024 were reprints, mostly in places like Black Cat Weekly or best-of anthologies, The other 23 were original stories. (This is one of the reasons the math doesn't always work--some of my stories that appeared in markets like Black Cat Weekly, Best Mystery Stories of the Year, etc., weren't actually submitted. They were instead requested or otherwise accepted outside the submission process.)


Observations

- As usual, most of my published stories appeared in AHMM, Strand Magazine, Mystery Magazine, Woman's World, Black Cat Weekly, and Black Cat Mystery Magazine. Also, three stories appeared in Storiaverse, which was a new animated concept but seems to have worked well.

- On the unusual side, I had only one private-eye story published this year, in the Strand. Eleven more PI stories have been accepted, though, and are awaiting publication.

- As in the past two years, I wrote more average-length to long stories in 2024 than very short stories. That'll probably be the case next year also, since (1) I'm writing fewer mini-mysteries for Woman's World and (2) Mystery Magazine recently (and sadly) put all four feet in the air. 

- For the second year in a row, I was fortunate enough to have a story in every issue of Strand Magazine. My story "Lizzy in the Morning," published earlier this month, marked my seventh straight story in that magazine. (And I have probably jinxed that streak by mentioning it here.) 

- Six of my published stories this year were installments from several of my mystery series. The rest were standalone stories.

- For maybe the first year since I started writing, I didn't dig out and rework any old and dusty stories that I gave up on long ago. In looking back over those half-finished efforts, I found that many were simply too bad to revisit and reconstruct. 

- Only two of my 2024 stories were set outside the U.S., and only two (not the same two) were published outside the U.S.

- Big difference, here, from last year: only about one-third of my published stories could be considered lighthearted and easygoing. The rest were more serious, and a bit violent. I think I've been watching too many of those cable series.

- Another difference: 16 of my 33 published stories were set in places outside the American South. I like writing Southern stories because I grew up here and live here and I know the geography and the people and the culture, but this year half the tales that popped into my head just happened to be set elsewhere, and relocating them wouldn't have worked. I also didn't write as many Westerns this year, for some reason.

- On a happy note, one of my stories won a 2024 Derringer Award for Best Short Story and was also selected for publication in both Best Mystery Stories of the Year 2024 and Best Crime Stories 2024 (UK).


Questions for you:

Have you noticed any trends this past year in your story writing (or, for that matter, reading)? Are they about the same length, content, genre, etc.? Any venturing out of your comfort zone, with your submissions? Are you targeting the same markets, or branching out a bit? Any surprises? Please let me know, in the comments section.


As always, I hope your holidays were happy, and I wish all you--writers and non-writers alike--a healthy and prosperous new year.

Back in two weeks . . .


28 comments:

  1. In the second paragraph above you mention laziness. Huh? So now you’re a comedian? Seriously, to say your accomplishments are impressive is an understatement. Congratulations!
    Edward Lodi

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Edward. No, I'm certainly lazy. I don't think fiction writing is hard work, maybe because it's so much fun. But I hate the business side of writing, and shirk it at every opportunity.

      Best to you in all writing endeavors!

      Delete
  2. Congratulations on your story appearing not one but two Best Mystery Stories of the year publications. Happy New Year!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks so much, Janice. But in truth, that second best-of (Best Crime Stories of the Year (Vol. 4, I think)), is the UK version of Best Mystery Stories of the Year 2024. So it's two different publications of the same story. I still sneakily counted it in the published column for my figures though. I don't yet have a copy of the 2024 edition but last time I was in it (Vol. 1, in 2021) I was able to order it via Amazon.

      Delete
  3. Congratulations on all your productivity, publications, and honors!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Eve. I am productive in some things, some of the time, but certainly not always. What I AM is extremely grateful for the luck I've had this year with some of the publications that you and I are both familiar with. (I still love seeing your name in ToC's, by the way--you've always been an inspiration to me at AHMM. Keep up the good work!)

      Delete
  4. My writing productivity wasn't quite up to your level (I'll provide my stats in my next post), but I did venture a bit out of my comfort zone with one submission: I sent a copy of one published story to the editors of The Best American Short Stories because I felt it might appeal to a readership beyond our genre. Fingers crossed.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Looking forward to seeing your post, Michael. You're still way ahead of me on story output over the years! Please let me know how the Best American Short Story submission turns out! And, as I noted elsewhere in these comments, thanks for finding my mistake regarding BC Weekly and BC Mystery Magazine.

      Delete
  5. Your productivity is amazing, John. Interesting that you say you weren't as "productive" last year as in previous years. Wow! I wish I was one tenth as productive.
    Congratulations.
    Bob

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Bob. Thank you for the kind words. Productivitywise, I had 44 stories published in 2020, 62 in 2021, 38 in 2022, and 57 in 2023, so I'm certainly lower this year.

      Believe me, I follow your accomplishments, and far as I'm concerned, you're doing great. Take care!

      Delete
  6. I don't know how you do it. But you sure are an inspiration!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. How kind of you! As for how I do it, my process is, I just sit around with a blank look on my face until an idea comes along, and I get a lot of ideas because I sit around a lot. Seriously, I always wonder if someday the idea well will run dry, and so far it hasn't.

      Thank you as always for your comment, Bob. Have a great 2025!

      Delete
  7. John, I really found it interesting, that your stories are becoming more serious this year. I seem to have gone the other way, testing the limits of loopiness, trying to find humour in a world that now frightens me, I suppose. I am in awe of your crime CV! (oops - that came out wrong...?)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Melodie, I found it interesting too, when I looked back over my published-this-year list. I usually prefer writing the lighthearted stories, and in fact I hope I'll get back to doing more of that. But for some reason this year I didn't, or at least didn't do it as much.

      I actually think the funny stories are easier to write, because (as you know) the writer has fun creating them!

      Delete
  8. Your numbers are FAR ahead of me. Until recently, I was submitting installments of a novella length series to AHMM, EQMM, and BCW. I also submitted a few short stories to these publications and others.

    The consensus being that my first couple of novellas were good enough to receive faulty contracts, despite not signing them. Another novella was good enough to be recommended and submitted elsewhere. A horror was liked by a couple of outlets to asked for a second story despite initial rejections. Also got good feedback on a sci-fi story and submitted it elsewhere. In short, the novellas are largely sitting there while the most recent novella and a few short stories are submitted to AHMM and a couple lesser known outlets.

    My self-published material dies well with an even bigger increase in sales on Amazon and Audible during the holidays, almost neck and neck on both outlets I'
    probably mentioned these details before, still working on a True Crime book to be released through those same outlets and a few older Kindle titles have resold recently. I plan on sprucing them up and do audiobook versions of each and the True Crime book. The self-published works pay for my family's gas and groceries.




    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Justin, I think you should be congratulated on--and encouraged by--the positive feedback you've received on those efforts, and I'm especially glad you recognized and turned down the faulty contracts. Good luck on those currently outstanding submissions!

      I'm also impressed by the success you've had with self-publishing. I wish you continued good fortune there. Hope you have a great new year!

      Delete
  9. CORRECTION! (And an apology): I said at one point in this post that some of my reprints appeared in Black Cat Mystery Magazine. I meant Black Cat Weekly (duh). Black Cat Mystery Magazine does not publish reprints. This was caught and pointed out to me by Michael Bracken, who either edits or co-edits both publications and who is by now accustomed to my blunders. That is now corrected--Thanks, Michael!

    ReplyDelete
  10. As always, John, your productivity and publishing successes are an inspiration to many of us! Sounds like you've had another amazing (or should I say "lucky"? LOL) year. And now that I have more time to write, I'll be using your results to inspire me in 2025!

    Thanks for sharing!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Chuck!--and yes, I think lucky's the correct word.

      I wish you the very best with your writing. Have a great year, and pleased keep me posted!

      Delete
  11. John, my own story trend is fewer than ever and longer than ever to get published after acceptance. At the top of my agenda this year is getting my new poetry collection published. As to your roundup, I no longer marvel about how prolific you are even in what you consider a lean year. I only wonder how you get any writing at all done considering the amount of time you spend watching movies! Oh, yeah, you said—you think them up in the middle of the night. It's your wife I should ask, as we therapists say, "And how do you feel about that?" ;) Happy New Year and happy writing!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Happy New Year to you too, Liz, and thanks for your kind words. As for watching movies, as I've told you before, it's research!! And no worries, when a story idea hits me in the middle of the night I don't bolt upright and yell Eureka!. What I do do is try har to remember it until morning, which doesn't always work.

      I wish you good luck with the poetry collection--that's exciting. You have my sincere congratulations--as I've mentioned before, I firmly believe it's far more difficult to write a good contemporary poem than to write a good short story. Go ahead on!!!

      Delete
  12. Oh, wow! That's amazing! Me? I promised myself I would finish a bunch of half-done stories
    and for about the first five months of the year, I think I did! Yes, holidays went well! Happy New Year to us all!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good for you, Jeff! It feels good to complete those half-finished stories, doesn't it? Best of luck with all of them. And yes, Happy 2025 to all.

      Delete
  13. Of course the word “journey” doesn’t work for you, John—you’ve already reached the destination, unpacked, and grabbed a rum punch by the pool! Congratulations on a super productive year, and especially on the accolades for Last Day at the Jackrabbit. I saw 6 stories in print and wrote 7, while continuing to work on several longer pieces. I ventured out of my comfort zone and wrote a story that was explicitly humorous. I find that it’s hard to be funny when I’m trying to be. It did get accepted by its intended publication, though… so I guess my strategy worked (not TRYING to be funny but imagining an over-the-top narrator in a ridiculous situation, and just trying to be true).
    So…still journeying for me, but hoping to make it to the 33-stories-in-a-year spot someday…hopefully there’s still rum punch at the bar when I get there!
    Ashley-Ruth Bernier

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ah, you are too kind, Ashley. Thank you. And it sounds to me like you did great last year--plus, I remember that many of those were published in fine markets. Special congratulations on trying--and completing, and selling!--that humorous story. Yep, the strategy worked!

      There's plenty of punch waiting--keep at it!

      Delete
  14. I was trying to pump myself up to write one short story a month in 2025 when I stumbled over here and discovered your productivity, John. Yikes! Most impressive.

    The harder you work, the luckier you get, right? It takes me upwards of a year to get rejected (Hello, AHMM!), so I'm amazed that you're able to get so much accepted and published in a given year. I'll be looking for your name in the future. Congratulations on your hard work and success. Merry New Year!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, John--but remember, many of my stories that were published this year were written LAST year, and many were even accepted last year. Sometimes publication takes a while, after acceptance.

      But you're right, the harder you work, the luckier (usually) you are. Except that I often find that the stories that are the most fun to write (in other words, those that DON'T require a lot of work) are the ones that are accepted by the best publications. Go figure. It's a crazy business.

      I wish you the very best in all your writing--may you have great success next year!

      Delete
    2. Oops. That last comment was mine, not some guy named Anonymous. My bad.

      Delete

Welcome. Please feel free to comment.

Our corporate secretary is notoriously lax when it comes to comments trapped in the spam folder. It may take Velma a few days to notice, usually after digging in a bottom drawer for a packet of seamed hose, a .38, her flask, or a cigarette.

She’s also sarcastically flip-lipped, but where else can a P.I. find a gal who can wield a candlestick phone, a typewriter, and a gat all at the same time? So bear with us, we value your comment. Once she finishes her Fatima Long Gold.

You can format HTML codes of <b>bold</b>, <i>italics</i>, and links: <a href="https://about.me/SleuthSayers">SleuthSayers</a>